Showing posts with label mortgages. Show all posts
Showing posts with label mortgages. Show all posts

Saturday, November 10, 2007

Parsing the Language on H.R. 3915



First and foremost, whatever the specifics of the bill it is an unmitigated disaster. It is full of vague language. Most of it is details are open to interpretation. As I mentioned in a previous post, this bill doesn't address the real problems that lead to the crisis, rather it assigns blame to targets that politicians think the public will cheerlead. This creates a bill that, in my opinion, will only continue to contribute to many of the problems that were in the market, and doesn't really do anything to resolve any of them.




First, there is an awful lot of confusion regarding the Yield Spread Premium portion of the bill. Some are claiming that it is eliminated. Brian Brady, of bloodhound realty blog, claims it is capped at 1%. Though, I have asked for him to source it and so far I have received no source. I cannot find any mention of capping YSP (for prime loans at least it is definitely eliminated for sub prime) in the summary I found. I also received an email late last night that said the the National Association of Mortgage Brokers (NAMB) was able to convince Frank of the importance of YSP. (not apparently so important for sub prime though) I will go with that for now, and just break down the rest of the bill. There are six areas of concern for me.




1) Again, a distinction is made between banks and brokers, and furthermore it creates a massive new government bureaucracy.






Provides for licensing and registration of individual mortgage brokers and registration of bank employees that originate mortgages, as well as the establishment of a Nationwide Mortgage Licensing System and Registry (NMLSR).

Now, as you can see, if you work for a bank, you only need to register whereas brokers need to go through all sorts of licensing on top of the registration. Now, here in Illinois, we already have such a law. It also distinguishes between brokers and bank employees. Brokers have to do all sorts of things while bank employees have to do nothing. This is just one example of many where Congress makes a distinction between those that originate loans through a broker and a bank. For instance, there is the cumbersome and bureaucratic nightmare known as SB 1167 here in Illinois. It forces, on certain loans, counseling mandated by the state for a fee of $300. This is of course only applies to brokers not banks. Banks already don't even have to disclose YSP like brokers do. The list goes on and on.


Furthermore, I was a stock broker before I was a mortgage broker and I can tell you that upon learning everything in the series 7 and 63, I never used any of that information EVER AGAIN. Maybe this new licensing will work, however if anyone has read the book, Freedomnomics, you know that most licensing programs only contribute to keeping good people out of any industry.




Second, this new NMLSR will create a giant new bureaucracy. Does anyone have confidence that the federal government will be able to track and monitor the fingerprints, background, testing, and monitoring of millions of mortgage professionals? Furthermore, there is this.






If a State does not have a system that meets the minimum standards for State-licensed loan originators or does not participate in the NMLSR, then HUD will establish a backup licensing system for loan originators that operate in that State. HUD will be granted enforcement authority over such loan originators similar to banking regulators.

The federal government won't only keep it all organized but it will even develop the model in those states that don't develop it themselves.




2)This bill will spell the end of sub prime. Right now, if sub prime were a boxer, it would have just been knocked down and is being given a standing eight count. Now, Congress just came in and is reigning haymakers.




First, YSP is eliminated, and if I read it right for brokers and bankers. (Retail banks rarely do sub prime loans anyway that loss would be minimal) Then, there is this.






prohibiting the financing of points and fees,

Now, keep in mind, without YSP, the only way anyone can make money is through points. Now, the government is saying I can't finance those within the borrower's loan. What that means in layman's terms is any fees and points charged have to be paid by the borrower at closing. Now, since sub prime is mostly geared toward the poor, this is probably not much of an option. Incentive has already been removed by elminating YSP and now the loans are even more difficult to get done because all the fees must be paid at closing. In other words, the government just totally screwed the very people it claims to protect. By enacting this bill we WILL go back to the elitist society we once had.




The irony is that this bill is supported by a plethora of consumer advocate groups. While they think it protects the poor from vultures like me, they can' t seem to realize that it also eliminates most of their options in buying a home to begin with.




3) Lot's of vague language and that will lead to lot's of new paperwork to sign.




That's right everyone. This should come as no surprise to anyone who has read my work. I pointed out before I realized there was an H.R. 3915 that Barney Frank thinks you don't sign enough paperwork. I counted seven separate places within the summary that will lead to new disclosures. There are words and phrases like: reasonable ability to pay (can you say the reasonable ability to pay disclosure), net tangible benefits (this will certainly be a disclosure since NTB is already a disclosure here in Illinois), presenting consumers with appropriate mortgages (the appropriate mortgage disclosure), unfair lending practices, predatory characteristics, the list is endless.




There are whole sections that are vague and thus will have many disclosures created to deal with them.






Qualified safe harbor mortgages are loans with (1) documented consumer income, (2) underwriting process based on fully indexed rate (taking into account taxes, insurance, and assessments), (3) no negative amortization, (4) other requirements that may be established by regulation, AND (5) one of the following: (i) fixed payment for at least 5 years, (ii) for variable-rate loans, APR that varies less than 3% over the interest-rate index, OR (iii) DTI not greater than a percentage prescribed by regulation.


Qualified safe harbor loans face almost no regulation and thus it will become very important for banks to establish that your loan is a safe harbor loan. No amount of paperwork will be too great in establishing that fact, and since they aren't the one signing anyway, we can all expect a whole host of new disclosures strictly to establish that your loan is a "safe harbor loan". Remember, as I pointed out already, one of the main reasons it is so easy to rip people off is because there is so much paperwork. Congress' solution to the problem is more paperwork.




4) This bill is either heavy handed to Wall Street or more likely it pays lip service to being heavy handed while actually doing nothing.






Assignee/Securitizer Liability (does not extend to trusts and investors): Subject to exemptions below, for loans that violate the minimum standards (reasonable ability to repay and net tangible benefits), a consumer has an individual cause of action against assignees and securitizers for rescission of the loan and the consumer’s costs for rescission.

Exemption from Liability: An assignee/securitizer will not be liable for a loan that violates the minimum standards if the assignee/securitizer provides a cure to make the loan conform to the minimum standards within 90 days of receiving notice from the consumer, OR (1) has a policy against buying mortgage loans that are not qualified mortgages or qualified safe harbor mortgages and exercises reasonable due diligence to adhere to such policy AND (2) has obtained representations and warranties from the seller or assignor of the loan regarding not selling or assigning loans that violate the minimum standards.[1]


If this is confusing, then everything is fine with you. (not with Congress mind you, just with you). If I read this correctly, Congress has established that borrowers that get into trouble can actually go after Wall Street, the securitizer. Now, imagine the nightmare that would cause. Wall Street securitizes millions of loans all at once and Congress wants each individual to be able to go after them. Now remember everyone, mortgage backed securities, the securitized, are out of favor with Wall Street already. Now, Congress wants to come in and allow for the potential of class action law suits against it.




Before you get too scared, I believe this is all lip service anyway. The second paragraph establishes outs for Wall Street. As long as they have a policy against securitizing bad loans and they have done their due diligence, they are immune. How vague is that? Wall Street securitizes billions of dollars worth of loans, or at least it used to, I hope it does its due diligence. This portion of a bill is a lawyer's dream, and ultimately it is impossible to know how anyone will respond to it. Wall Street may see this as reason enough to never go back to this market, or they may realize that Frank put this in only to look as though he is being tough on them.




5) If I read it correctly, this bill actually incentivizes a borrower to get foreclosed on. Remember, there is no way that the politicians would ever hold any irresponsible borrower responsible for any of this. That wouldn't play well politically. Thus, they are doing everything they can to protect the borrower from more problems. (except for the problem of signing more paperwork) This portion is one of several places where they do that and of course the portion regarding Wall Street is another.




When the holder of a mortgage loan or anyone acting on behalf of the holder initiates a judicial or non-judicial foreclosure, (1) the consumer who has a rescission right under this bill may assert such right as a defense to foreclosure against the holder to forestall foreclosure, or (2) if the rescission right has expired, the consumer may seek actual damages (plus costs) against the creditor, assignee, or securitizer.




First, it takes up to nine months and more after payments have been stopped for someone to lose their homes already. This bill will add even more time to that process. In the meantime, a bank receives no payment. While I can sympathize with a borrower that got in over their heads, how about some sympathy for a bank that loans hundreds of thousands and receives no payment for a year and more.




It is portion two that scares me. I can't make heads or tails of it. I can see it being interpreted though as allowing borrowers recourse for lawsuit if they are foreclosed on. Doesn't that sound like an incentive to allow foreclosure.




Yes, the entire section is quite vague and, if you have being paying attention, the practical effect is that YOU HAVEN'T SIGNED ENOUGH PAPERWORK YET. This section will likely have dozens of new disclosures to address it.




6) Finally, there is mention of a new counseling program. I have already referenced the counseling program here in Illinois. While SB 1167 hasn't yet been enacted, its earlier reincarnation HB 4050 did enough damage. It applied to only a handful of zip codes. Take a look, here are the sales figures from those zip codes.







60620 experienced a 43% drop in sales
60621 experienced a 25% drop in sales
60623 experienced a 57% drop in sales
60628 experienced a 15% drop in sales
60629 experienced a 63% drop in sales
60632 experienced a 34% drop in sales
60636 experienced a 41% drop in sales
60638 experienced a 54% drop in sales
60643 experienced a 49% drop in sales
60652 experienced a 43% drop in sales


If you have come to my blog often, then you know my favorite quote. This bill is the perfect vehicle for that quote so I will end the piece with Ronald Reagan,






the nine most terrifying words in the English language are 'I'm from the government and I'm here to help'

I know that H.R. 3915 terrifies me.

Tuesday, October 2, 2007

The Practical Effect of Government Regulation vis a vis Mortgages

In response to the recent mortgage crisis, the Nevada state legislature sprang into action.


Unclear wording in a new law to block bogus real estate deals could make it
tougher for some qualified Nevadans to get home loans, and no hearings on rules
to resolve the problem have been held — even though the rules must be in place
by Oct. 1.

The problems with AB440 of the 2007 session comes at a bad time — with
Nevada ranked No. 1 in the nation for foreclosure rates on home loans and
experiencing a slowdown in home sales that mirrors a national pattern.

Mendy Elliott, head of the state Department of Business and Industry, said
Monday the hearings on the AB440 rules will be held, with a goal of adopting
regulations that ensure mortgage lending isn’t “shut down in the state.”

Elliott also said the state is working on other projects to ease the
mortgage lending crisis. That could include a requirement for credit counseling
sessions for prospective borrowers and the use of bond revenue to help some
borrowers.Assemblyman Marcus Conklin, D-Las Vegas, prime sponsor of AB440, said
the idea of his bill was to protect consumers, and nobody involved in the
legislation wanted to “slow up the process for qualified people” trying to buy
homes.

Conklin said that he plans to talk with Elliott about the regulation
process, adding that he thinks any confusion over the new law “will clear up
fairly easily.” If necessary, he said an emergency regulation could speed up the
process.Some major lenders recently expressed concerns about AB440. Ironically,
the banking industry came up with a late-session amendment that was designed to
give the measure flexibility but also inserted the fuzzy wording regarding
lending practices.


This article is thick with irony, for instance there is this quote, "with a goal of adopting regulations that ensure mortgage lending isn’t “shut down in the state". Why is this ironic. Well, wouldn't you know it, the first practical effect of this law is felt. Flagstar just sent me an internal memo saying that they are discontinuing most of their products in that state. Nothing to help a mortgage crisis like lenders picking off mortgages several at a time. (Please note there is no link for that would be illegal you will have to take my word for it)

The naysayers may say that this one bank and only a group of mortgages, and the naysayers would be wrong. Nebulus laws are not something that lenders want to deal with. If you don't believe me, just look at what happened vis a vis HB 4050, which sounds like pretty much the same law in my state, Illinois.

What was the practical effect of that law. Let's look at real estate transactions in the zip codes it applied in. This is one month after inception...

60620 experienced a 43% drop in sales
60621 experienced a 25% drop in sales
60623 experienced a 57% drop in sales
60628 experienced a 15% drop in sales
60629 experienced a 63% drop in sales
60632 experienced a 34% drop in sales
60636 experienced a 41% drop in sales
60638 experienced a 54% drop in sales
60643 experienced a 49% drop in sales
60652 experienced a 43% drop in sales

You got a hand it to politicians. Only they could look at one state, see a law failed miserably, and say, hey maybe that is something we should try here.
The banks usually work like a mob and we should all expect for lenders one by one in the next couple of weeks to remove all or most of their products from that state while this law is fleshed out. For the people of the state of Nevada, too bad so sad, as one of my friends loved to say, you will just have to deal with nearly no lenders lending in your state.
My favorite Reagan quote applies again,

"The nine most terrifying words in the English language are 'I'm from the government and I'm here to help'"

Tuesday, September 4, 2007

Is Liquidity Coming Back to the Mortgage Market?

So says Dan Green over at themortgagereports.com.



Good News For Mortgages #1: Pricing incentives on jumbo loans
A very
large bank is offering pricing incentives for all jumbo, fixed, full
documentation loans. If you meet the criteria below, your rates won't be
as bad you may have been told.
Mortgage greater than $600,000 mortgage
30-year fixed mortgage
Willing to prove income and asset with
documentation
So far, I only know one bank that is making this discount
available. You may need to work with a broker to make sure you get it, or
hope that you do your banking there.

Good News For Mortgages #2: Large Alt-A lender places jumbo mortgages
in secondary market

IndyMac sold $590 million in mortgage bonds to the markets for the first
time since July.
About 40% of those bonds were rated "AAA", meaning the risk is deemed to as
close to nil as possible. Only government bonds are rated
safer.
IndyMac's placed offerings were for jumbo mortgages.

Good News For Mortgages #3: Foreign National lending pricing continues to
improve
Foreign National lending is a niche and one in which I like to
work. It's very encouraging to see that mortgage
rates are still improving
for this portfolio product. Lending to a
non-U.S. citizen can be a risky proposition for a bank because a foreign
borrower has a different incentive system to pay a mortgage.

If a U.S. citizen walks away on a mortgage from a U.S. bank, getting a loan
from another bank in the future is a huge challenge. For a foreign
national, it just means limiting their real estate exposure to the other
193 countries in the world
.
Because the risk premium is reducing for
foreign nationals from Ireland, England, Spain or wherever, it suggests brighter
skies for all mortgage borrowers.

I am personally less optimistic. My evidence is no less anecdotal than Dan's however, what industry insiders are telling me about default rates is downright scary.

One account rep, told me that at their bank 35% of their second mortgages are currently in default. This bank happens to be a sub prime bank. Let me tell you why this is scary. Second mortgages were done on high combined loan to value loans. The second mortgage, for all intends and purposes, cannot foreclose. The reason is if they tried the first mortgage would get first dibbs and they would get whatever is left, which 99.9% of the time is nothing. The borrowers know this and so what many who can't afford their mortgage do, is not pay the second. That means that these borrowers aren't really paying their mortgage back, but rather manipulating the system to keep their homes. These first second combos were extremely popular and made up an overwhelming amount of sub prime loans, well over 50%. If 35% of these seconds are delinquent (and at least with this bank they are), then I think default rates are much higher than what is currently being estimated.

Another account rep tells me that they cut all of the Alt A products because upon analysis they found that their worst performing Alt A loans, were the stated loans with the highest credit scores. Now, if high credit score borrowers are defaulting at unusually high rates, then again, we haven't seen the worst yet.

Thursday, July 26, 2007

SB 1167 and My Favorite Reagan Quote

Today the Illinois Senate Passed SB 1167. This is a new version of a disastrous bill known as HB 4050. Because fraud is so pravalent in the mortgage industry, the politicians in Springfield felt they had to do something. This bill calls for in some cases that borrowers before they can close on a loan that they meet with a state certified representative to discuss the loan. While this may all sound good in theory, in practice it is not only an intrusion, but a looming disaster for all.

While HB 1167 hasn't been finalized here are the basics of HB 4050

HB 4050 is a pilot program in Cook County (Illinois) designed to protect
mortgage applicants from unscrupulous loan originators.
The pilot
program lasts four years.
HB 4050 was passed in July 2005 and became
Illinois state law January 1, 2006. It will not be implemented and
enforced until the physical database to compile and store data is completed,
however.
HB 4050 applies to state-chartered loan originators (i.e. mortgage
brokers and local mortgage bankers). Therefore, federally-chartered banks
are exempt (i.e. Chase, National City, Fifth Third, Bank of America) from the
law.
HB 4050 requires "High Risk" individuals to receive financial advice
from federally-approved financial counselors before completing a mortgage
transaction.
The definition of "High Risk" is stated in the rules of the
law. These are summarized as follows:
Applicant FICO
score is less than 620, or
Applicant FICO score is between 621-650 and any
one of these conditions is true:
Subject property was financed within the
last 12 months
Mortgage product has an Interest Only feature
Mortgage
product is an ARM with an initial fixed period of 3 years or less
Mortgage
application does not require the verification of applicant's income
Mortgage
product contains a prepayment penalty
Mortgage product contains a negative
amortization feature (i.e. Option ARM)
Total points and fees payable by
borrower at, or before, closing exceeds 5% of the loan size
HB 4050 does not
apply to all of Cook County. It only applies to designated zip
codes. This is a map of
those zip codes
. We also created an overlay
map
of the pilot program with a map of areas in which mortgage fraud has
occured

Some of you may have read my recent diary about Illinois High Cost and my favorite Reagan quote. The principle is the same here. On certain mortgages the government has decided that the consumer is not smart enough to make decisions on their own and so the government will step in and before the deal is finalized they will scrutinize the decision. Imagine if before you bought a car, you had to meet with a government sponsored counselor to make sure that car did in fact fit your needs. Imagine putting in any other product or service in place of a mortgage and see if that is something that you would stand for.

When HB 4050 passed, a great many banks simply decided not to lend in the areas affected. What this did was it drove real estate down in those areas. Just take a look at this chart...


60620 experienced a 43% drop in sales
60621 experienced a 25% drop in sales
60623 experienced a 57% drop in sales
60628 experienced a 15% drop in sales
60629 experienced a 63% drop in sales
60632 experienced a 34% drop in sales
60636 experienced a 41% drop in sales
60638 experienced a 54% drop in sales
60643 experienced a 49% drop in sales
60652 experienced a 43% drop in sales
Compared to September 2005, one year ago, sales were also down 45% in the target zip codes. So, we can say with near certainty that the plummet is not strictly seasonal. The breakdown by zip code:
60620 experienced a 28% drop in sales
60621 experienced a 37% drop in sales
60623 experienced a 61% drop in sales
60628 experienced a 17% drop in sales
60629 experienced a 70% drop in sales
60632 experienced a 54% drop in sales
60636 experienced a 1% drop in sales
60638 experienced a 65% drop in sales
60643 experienced a 49% drop in sales
60652 experienced a 41% drop in sales

As you can see each zip code affected by HB 4050 experienced a drop off in sales. HB 4050 was wrong on principle, however the government though it was wrong because it isolated certain zip codes, poor zip codes, and they thought this, and this only, was wrong. Look again at the sales figures for every zip code affected by HB 4050. Apparently the government wasn't satisfied with dropping off sales in a select few zip codes because the new law will cover the entire County of Cook. Now, if HB 4050 caused drops in every zip code it affected, what do you think will happen if there is a new law that does the same thing in the whole county?

Once again, my favorite Reagan quote applies, "the nine most dangerous words in the English language are 'I'm from the government and I'm here to help'". Yes, there is way too much fraud in the mortgage industry and it is a problem that can be catastrophic, however the answer is NOT for the government to step in and create even more bureaucracy to a process that is already insanely bureaucratic. Anyone who has gotten a mortgage probably remembers wanting to pull their hair out from all of the paperwork waiting and red tape. Now, the government wants to add yet another layer of bureaucracy to a process that usually drives people crazy as it is.

That's right. The government thinks most of you are too stupid or too unscrupulous to make your own decisions with your own mortgage. So, before you can make a decision, you need to meet with a counselor, for $300, and talk to them and explain yourself to them. Does this sound like the sort of liberty that the great Thomas Paine wanted to die for?